By Jacob G. Hornberger
PaulCraigRoberts.org
November 19, 2026
As part of a peace agreement to end Russia's war with Ukraine, Russian President Vladimir Putin is demanding that NATO pull back its troops and infrastructure to positions held in 1997, before NATO began expanding toward Russia's borders.
It is certainly understandable why Russia would not want this Cold War dinosaur on or near its borders, especially given two points:
First, NATO is dominated and controlled by the U.S. national-security establishment, which has a long history of military interventions, invasions, wars of aggression, regime-change operations, assassinations, and wars around the world. What independent nation that isn't a member of the U.S. Empire would feel comfortable having U.S. troops, nuclear missiles, tanks, and armaments on its border?
Second, NATO includes Germany, which wreaked untold death and destruction on Russia in World War II and, in fact, came close to conquering the country. Given that history, what Russian citizen would want German troops on or near the Russian border?
But as reasonable as Putin's demand is, it's not enough. NATO needs to be disbanded and dismantled. It needs to be cast into the dustbin of history.
NATO was formed after World War II for the ostensible purpose of protecting Western Europe from a Soviet invasion. But there was never any reasonable possibility of a Soviet invasion. The last thing the Soviet Union wanted was another war, especially given that Russia, including much of its industrial capacity, had been almost entirely destroyed during the war.
Moreover, the Soviets knew that if they invaded Western Europe, it was a virtual certainty that the United States would come to the defense of Western Europe, even without a NATO. At that time, the U.S. had a vast nuclear superiority over the Soviet Union and had demonstrated a willingness to use nuclear bombs on populated cities. There was never any reasonable possibility that the Russians would take the chance of having Moscow, Leningrad, and other Russian cities vaporized by U.S. nuclear weapons.
Thus, there was never any good reason for NATO to come into existence in the first place. When it did come into existence, it became a centerpiece of the Cold War racket that revolved around the ridiculous notion that there was a worldwide communist conspiracy to take over the world that was centered in Moscow. "The Russians are coming ! Look under your bed for a Red," Americans were told.
The Cold War was nothing more than a racket that was used to justify the conversion of the federal government from a limited-government republic to a national-security state, which came with omnipotent, totalitarian-like powers, such as assassination. It was also a racket that was used to justify the ever-increasing tax-funded budgets for the national-security establishment and its ever-growing army of fat-cat "defense" contractors.
When the Cold War ostensibly came to an end in 1989-1991, there was no reason to keep NATO in existence. Since the Soviet Union was dismantling and withdrawing its troops from Eastern European countries, NATO had lost its justification for existing.
But the Pentagon, the CIA, and the NSA were not about to let go of what had been an enormous cash cow for them. Even though the Warsaw Pact was going out of existence, the U.S. military-intelligence establishment refused to permit NATO to do the same.
Nonetheless, Russian officials secured a promise from U.S. officials that NATO would stay right where it was - no expansion toward Russia.
Unfortunately, however, the Pentagon, CIA, and NSA ignored those U.S. promises and gradually proceeded to use NATO to expand eastward, absorbing former members of the Warsaw Pact. In April 2008, NATO formally declared that Ukraine and Georgia would eventually become members of the alliance. That decision meant that NATO was openly contemplating extending its military alliance all the way to Russia's borders, notwithstanding longstanding Russian objections.
That's why Russia invaded Ukraine - to prevent that from happening. That's why the U.S. national-security establishment is ultimately responsible for all the death and destruction arising from the Russia-Ukraine war, which is actually a U.S.-Russia war in which the Ukraine is serving as an agent or proxy for the United States.
Let's imagine that Russia and China enter into a new organization called the Communist Coalition. Let's imagine that Cuba and Mexico voluntarily and eagerly join the coalition. Let's imagine that Russia, China, Cuba, and Mexico announce plans to install Russian and Chinese nuclear missiles, troops, tanks, drones, and armaments in Cuba and along the Mexico-U.S. border.
We don't have to speculate about how U.S. officials would react to such a development. During the Cuban Missile Crisis in 1962, President Kennedy was prepared to risk nuclear war rather than permit Soviet nuclear missiles to remain in Cuba. Given that U.S. government response to Soviet missiles in Cuba in 1962, does anyone seriously doubt that American officials would initiate military action against Cuba and Mexico to prevent Russia and China from deploying missiles and troops in Cuba and along the Mexico-U.S. border?
The Cold War ostensibly ended more than three decades ago. Putin's demand for a NATO pullback is understandable. But it doesn't go far enough. It's time to permanently terminate this dangerous Cold War dinosaur.
This article was originally published at The Future of Freedom Foundation.