
Martin Jay
Sanctioning an Irish RT journalist signals that the EU is worried that the war in Ukraine is coming to an end and that Brussels is reaching a new level of panic.
Sanctioning an Irish RT journalist signals that the EU is worried that the war in Ukraine is coming to an end and that Brussels is reaching a new level of panic.
Just recently the EU gate-crashed the Abu Dhabi Ukraine-Russia talks, which raised eyebrows around the world, as, generally speaking, most superpowers (even wannabe superpowers) don't usually resort to such despairing measures. In the event, the EU couldn't even agree on finding an individual to represent them and their proxy, Ukraine. Pathetic.
But there doesn't seem to be anyone in Brussels advising Ursula von der Leyen about media and the international image that the EU is projecting through badly thought-through stunts like Abu Dhabi.
The recent news that the RT Irish commentator Chay Bowes is a good example. After blowing off both of its feet with a shotgun over the disastrous decision to sanction Russian oil - which has crippled EU economies, practically bringing them to their knees - the EU has a bright new idea to redirect any opprobrium or navel-gazing over its own self-destruction: to target journalists or those working in the media on the Russian side.
This is such a stupid idea I hardly know where to start. But the most fundamental point which any media hack knows is that this strategy always backfires on those who instigate it, as it delivers a number of key messages which won't do Brussels any favours. One, if you hadn't previously heard of Chay Bowes, this sanction against him - which freezes his bank accounts and enforces a travel ban - means you sure know who he is now, and so his profile is raised considerably. Secondly, most people will assume that Bowes must be doing some good work and he must be worth following now if the EU is going to this level to destroy his life (correct); and thirdly, perhaps going to this level and targeting those working for Russian media sends out a signal that only a losing side can muster. Most folks in Ohio who don't follow the war in Ukraine might just assume that the West is losing and so has to resort to this kind of pathetic intimidation of humble Irish journalists.
Like all out-of-control dictatorships in their final throes, the momentum of doing away with external consultants and only listening to your own echo chamber of carefully chosen sycophants comes with a price. Isn't this the lesson for Trump and the midterms ? Ever since I arrived in Brussels in 1995 to cover the EU for a number of British titles, I have noticed it making more and more stupid mistakes when it comes to its international image. It has very well-paid ex-journalists advising it, but I'm quite sure those consultants have learnt the lesson of not rocking the boat by giving advice which will upset the boss. From an international PR perspective, sanctioning Chay Bowes is profoundly stupid and almost certainly comes down to the European Commission president herself, as in recent years, under her watch, the EU has become even more authoritarian and indulged itself increasingly with an Orwellian mindset.
The EU has never liked any journalists who tell a story which clashes with its own narrative. Hans-Martin Tillack, a German investigative journalist, was arrested in Brussels in 2004 by Belgian police, on the instruction of EU judges, for simply being a good journalist and getting scoops about internal corruption. Police came to his house at 5 a.m. and took him and his computers. One Belgian cop told him, "Yeah, but it's not as bad as Burma, eh?" I also received a high court injunction in the same year by a Belgian court which ruled in my absence that I was to be fined 8,000 euros for publishing an article which lifted the lid on the Belgian paedophile network and the dirty role the EU played in protecting it, even giving jobs to the ringleaders outside of Belgium to protect them from prosecution. Being told by a former Belgian secret service guy that it was pointless keeping my Spanish shotgun under my bed as "if they're coming for you, they won't kill you in your home" was not much comfort, and I assumed a travel ban was in place, although I never tested it. The cheap intimidation tricks to finally get me to leave the country and fold my magazine was a fabricated, extortionate VAT bill which did the trick. For my former partner on the magazine, it was less subtle. Authorities sent social workers to his house to inspect his children for signs of sexual abuse.
So I know what Chay Bowes is going through now, as I've been there more than once - and I note that perhaps the sanction against him has a second layer to it, in that Bowes is a very rare Irishman in that he is Eurosceptic - perhaps also a defining, petulant point in the EU action.
The travel ban is particularly nasty, as, after a period of time, it will bite when the reality of not being able to be with loved ones or family for a bereavement in Ireland will crush him. This is the barbaric component of the sanctions for an Irishman living and working in Moscow, and it projects the EU as a medieval feudal power which might as well burn women with long hair at the stake. Not very progressive - and perhaps hardly surprising that the EU club's executive in Brussels is losing all sense of reality as it continues to invest in the war racket of Ukraine, while EU economies burn around them and it inevitably has to ask its members to double the normal budget contribution, as the failed machine just keeps on taking more and more money without producing any tangible derivative other than to keep its rulers in jobs. This Soviet model doesn't have any new models of governance to save Europe. It doesn't have strategies to build new companies, create jobs and attract foreign investment. These days it doesn't even bother to pretend that it can even come close to achieving even a token of any of those aspirations, and it certainly can't hope to organise any armies to fight the Russians. All it seems to be able to do is to continue to drip-feed the Ukrainian regime with military aid while yet another German company leaves its own country altogether. Who would invest in Germany, after all, if even Mercedes itself won't ? Who would give Ursula von der Leyen a top executive job when she leaves her current one as Commission president (apart from Pfizer) ? The sanctions against journalists are a record new low point for the EU, as it is now running wild, panicking like a circus big cat which is running around a German village knowing that its days are numbered before the inevitable bullet to the temple comes. Chay Bowes basically won an esteemed press award, and I hope his colleagues present him with a gong, as his work on the Ukraine war we now know must be pretty good, given that the EU needs to put an end to it.