How Chicago's Colorful Crooks Gave Way to Politicians Who Won't Even Steal Properly
November 21, 2026
No child of Chicago is unfamiliar with political vote buying. It is a badge of civic pride. We were not the first; that honor has to go to Boss Tweed and Tammany Hall in New York. But we try harder. Tweed and his posse were famous for inflated contracts, crooked bookkeeping, and plundering municipal government in a truly stylized fashion. If only New York were so well run these days. Because despite the massive corruption, Tweed had adapted his machine to a city of immigrants, unfamiliar languages, thin public services, and hard luck finding employment. Tweed was dirty, sure, but a district captain might find a man a job, arrange a little food, or surprise a family with a turkey on Christmas. Come election time, the district captain called all the favors in. But Tweed's machine was not purely predatory; it could be useful and even humane at times. In New York, people distinguished between "honest graft" and "dishonest graft." Sure, a politician might save a little for himself in putting together a neighborhood improvement, but let's be serious.
Chicago's Mike McDonald was also a pioneer of corruption. McDonald was the gambling kingpin who discovered that buying politicians was less efficient than building an entire political machine to elect them. By converting gambling profits into political influence and political protection back into profits, McDonald helped turn corruption into a self-sustaining enterprise. He was the George Washington of Chicago corruption, and it is truly sad that he does not receive the plaudits that more derivative political crooks receive. King Mike McDonald, who had spent decades corrupting Chicago's politicians and evading the law, was finally brought down by something he could neither purchase nor control: his wife's infidelity. When his much younger wife murdered her lover in 1907, the scandal shattered the aging political boss, who died six months later. Chicago's king of corruption had survived everything except a broken heart. It was a tender love story, Chicago style.
After McDonald's demise, Michael "Hinky Dink" Kenna and John "Bathhouse" Coughlin presided over the famous First Ward's despicable combination of saloons, prostitution, petty crime, and electoral efficiency. The annual First Ward Ball put on display a political culture that was extraordinary for the depth and breadth of its depravity. There was "Big Jim" Colosimo, the notorious vice lord and brothel operator who preceded Al Capone. There were the famous Everleigh sisters, the striking proprietors of Chicago's luxurious Everleigh Club brothel. There was Big Jim O'Leary, the gambling kingpin whose mother's cow is said to be responsible for the Chicago Fire. And then the usual assortment of pickpockets, burglars, pimps, madams, professional gamblers, two-bit crooked politicians, and crooked police captains.
But it wasn't just underworld guys who were the crooks in 19th-century Chicago. Everyone got into the act. Aldermen routinely traded in corrupt franchises and municipal deals. A street easement, railway privilege, or city license was seen as a private opportunity by the aldermen, who are said to have organized things so well that there were regular prices depending upon the type of graft. The famous British journalist W. T. Stead, upon his visit to Chicago, regaled the public in his bestseller If Christ Came to Chicago with the story of an alderman who changed his position in mid-speech upon the arrival of a bulging envelope. Oh, Chicago, I miss you.
I would be remiss if I did not reminisce about the glory days of my own childhood and the late Richard J. Daley. Daley was a perfectionist, and he brought machine politics into a more disciplined age. Hailing from hard Irish and racist Bridgeport on the city's South Side, he developed a well-oiled machine that relied on ward committeemen, precinct workers, city employment, and a dense network of political obligations. He also happened to get a lot of things done for the city, and the two Daleys, Richard J. and Richard M., converted Chicago from a meat-packing hellhole into one of the most beautiful cities in America. But Boy Scouts they were not.
And just to show that Chicago once had a bipartisan spirit, before Daley there was William Hale "Big Bill" Thompson, Chicago's astoundingly shameless mayor during the Capone era. Big Bill knew how to make headlines, once even promising to punch the King of England in the snoot. What was terrific and innovative about Bill was that he campaigned against corruption while presiding over an administration that was famous for its accommodation of Capone and other gangsters. Big Bill even staged a political debate with two live rats representing his opponents. Capone even financed his campaigns. Bill was a Republican, Daley a Democrat, but anyone from Illinois knows that Democratic and Republican governors have visited downstate penitentiaries.
Chicagoans of the 20th century had a framework and certainty to the way business was conducted. If you wanted a variance, you had to ask around, or if you wanted a ticket fixed, the going rate was usually $150. There was structure; the Cubs always found new ways to lose, winter was terrible, and getting something done simply required asking around to find whom to pay. But there was a humanity to it: the ward boss remembered the widow's name, someone remembered when someone was snowed in, the Daleys always made sure the roads were shoveled in the winter, and the crime was confined to certain parts of town. People knew the boundaries. There was a quiet understanding and even a civic sophistication to it all.
But now, in this age when we claim to somehow be more civilized, our politicians have lately demonstrated a shamelessness that would make old Bathhouse and Hinky Dink blush. The humanity has gone out of all of the graft and corruption-and the creativity along with it. Today's crooks aren't even thinking men's crooks. They are apes.
Our current politicians have determined that it is too much effort to maintain a ward clubhouse, rescue orphans, or visit grieving police widows. Our politicians are too self-absorbed to even learn anyone's name or find anyone a job. That's just too damn hard, I guess. No envelopes are passed in backrooms or secret apartments where deals are made above brothels. All the romance is gone. Just a podium, a teleprompter, and a solemn promise to send people money. In Chicago, we at least have the decency to buy your vote with a patronage job, concert tickets, or a paid-for hotel room. But our lazy and worthless politicians are now pledging to simply send checks. Trump floated "tariff dividend checks" and a "DOGE dividend." Joe Biden was a champion of "pandemic relief checks." The new governor-elect of Texas simply promised everyone a check.
It is one thing to be taken for greedy, but quite another to be taken for stupid. Government possesses no secret orchard in which money ripens each autumn. Public funds come from taxes, fees, royalties, investment returns, or borrowing, each with its own distributional consequences. Even a rebate from a genuine surplus presents a choice: return the money, preserve reserves, reduce debt, or fund some other purpose. These politicians have generously offered to send us a gift of our own money. What swell guys and gals.
There's a word for a guy who goes out and buys a diamond engagement ring on his girlfriend's charge card. But now these people are all over our government. The new benevolent governor-elect of Texas, a real winner, has promised to make this $1,500 payment through a "multi-billion-dollar drawdown of reserves." Not only utterly shameless, but the opposite of what any politician should be doing with the state's reserve fund. For crissake, even Mayor Daley balanced his budget.
Perhaps the real difference between the old bosses and their classless successors is that while the former stole shamelessly, at least they often knew the neighborhoods from which their power came. These undesirables treat the whole country or whole state as their ward, distribute false promises on an industrial scale, and never shake the hand of a single beneficiary. The personal obligation has utterly vanished while political calculation remains.
The old bosses bought loyalty with a handshake, a job, a turkey, and a little boodle. Their modern successors have discovered that the same appeal can be delivered electronically, advertised nationally, and financed through the public purse. The spectacle of candidates competing to claim credit for handing out crumbs of the public's own money deserves all the ridicule a free people can muster.
Perhaps Tweed would have admired the reach, and Hinky Dink would have marveled at the turnout. But maybe it's the romantic in me: I like to think that there is something very hollow about asking for a vote when you don't even buy the drinks yourself.
This article was originally published at Abstract Truth Substack.